Description
A set of routines for design reviews: predict and rehearse stakeholder objections, answer feedback with a structured IDEAL response, and record decisions with notes and a fast follow-up.
Greever treats stakeholder meetings as a design problem. Before the review, remove known distractions (placeholder content, disliked legacy elements), note what each attendee cares about and has objected to before, write expected objections by screen with planned responses, prepare alternatives and data held in reserve, brief allies openly, and rehearse aloud. During the meeting, answer feedback by thanking, repeating the point back and preparing the listener, then giving an IDEAL response: Identify the problem, Describe the solution, Empathise with the user through one concrete story, Appeal to the business ('this design will affect this goal because'), Lock in agreement by asking directly. Tactics include side-by-side comparison and exposing trade-offs. A note-taker records who suggested and agreed to what, marks decisions as final or uncertain and assigns owners; a recap goes out within an hour, creating a decision record.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Design & Product Practice
- Loss type
- Active
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- Remove distractions known to derail particular attendees, such as placeholder text and rough alignment.
- For each attendee note goals, likes, dislikes and past reactions; write expected objections by screen with a planned response.
- Prepare alternatives (including rejected versions) for side-by-side comparison and supporting data held in reserve.
- Brief allies openly, write an agenda and rehearse the meeting aloud with mock questions.
- In the meeting, respond to feedback with thank, repeat, prepare, then identify the problem, describe the solution, empathise with the user, appeal to the business and lock in agreement.
- Have a colleague take shared notes recording who suggested and agreed to what, with decisions marked final or uncertain and owners assigned.
- Within an hour (at most a day) send a recap of decisions, actions with owners and dates, and open questions.
Sources
- Articulating Design Decisions (Greever, 2015)
- Design Is a Job (Monteiro, 2012)
Related talks
Also known as
- Objection rehearsal
- Design review preparation
- Note buddy
- Meeting follow-up recap
- IDEAL response
- Thank-Repeat-Prepare
Categories
- Design
- Design & Product Practice