Description
Structured review of design work to give useful, evidence-based feedback that improves the solution.
Design critique is a structured discussion of how well a design meets its objectives. Present the work with its purpose and relevant context, then invite colleagues from different disciplines to identify strengths, problems and questions. Ground feedback in the intended outcome rather than personal taste or judgement of the designer. Use critique while work can still change, repeating it as the design develops. It provides informed perspectives for improvement; it is distinct from a final approval meeting or an expert compliance review.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Design & Product Practice
- Loss type
- Active
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- Agree the foundation: personas, scenarios, goals and principles the work must serve.
- Choose about six or fewer cross-functional participants and define the scope (components and objectives) and the decisions needed afterwards.
- Send designs, focus notes and rules a couple of days ahead rather than revealing work in the session.
- Open by restating rules and objectives; present briefly from the user's perspective.
- Have participants critique with the four questions, using round robin, quotas or a single shared lens (a thinking hat or persona) at a time; one person takes public notes and problem solving is parked.
- For charts or readouts, have a reviewer think aloud about where their eyes go first and what the main message is, then recall it after it is put away.
- Within a day share notes, sort feedback into accept, reject or consider, reframe notes as actions with owners, and record what will not be addressed and why.
Sources
- Universal Methods of Design (Martin & Hanington, 2019)
- Discussing Design (Connor & Irizarry, 2015)
- Storytelling with Data: Let's Practice! (Knaflic, 2020)
- User Experience Management (Lund, 2011)
- Design Is a Job (Monteiro, 2012)
- Prototyping for Designers (McElroy, 2016)
Videos
Related talks
Also known as
- design crit
- crit session
- design review
- Crit
- Structured design critique
- Objective-based design critique
- Critical Response Process
- Ritual dissent
- Six Thinking Hats as lens-based critique
- Four-question critique framework
- Fresh-eyes feedback
- Feedback speed dating
- I like, I have questions, I'd suggest
Categories
- Design
- Design & Product Practice