Word-of-Mouth Economics and Bad-Profits Audit

Description

Put a money value on a promoter's referrals and a detractor's negative word of mouth, then audit and remove policies that earn revenue by creating detractors.

Two linked analyses from the Net Promoter system. Word-of-mouth economics values comments: new customers are asked their main reason for choosing the firm, and all customers how many positive and negative comments they made in the past year and how many positives neutralise one negative. In the Dell case, referred customers worth $210 each and about 40 million positive comments gave $5.25 per comment; promoters made about eight a year, and detractors about four negatives, each cancelling five positives. Adding spend, tenure and service-cost differences valued a promoter at $328 and a detractor at -$57. Rules of thumb: one negative neutralises three to ten positives, and 80-90% of referrals come from promoters. The bad-profits audit then finds revenue earned at customers' expense (nuisance fees, gotcha pricing, onerous contracts, misleading sales) using detractor root causes, defector interviews and employee rankings, and sets a dated removal plan that finance will defend.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Data
Mixed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Ask new customers the main reason they chose the firm, and record the share citing a referral.
  2. Ask the recommend question and count positive and negative comments made in the past year; ask how many positives neutralise one negative.
  3. Value one positive comment as referred-customer value divided by total positive comments, and value promoters and detractors by comment counts plus spend, tenure and service-cost differences.
  4. Collect detractor root causes and defector accounts to identify policies that create detractors.
  5. Ask employees to rank-order the most egregious bad-profit practices and discuss them openly.
  6. Quantify the revenue at stake against the cost of the detractors each policy creates.
  7. Agree and publish a dated removal plan with finance sign-off.

Sources

  • The Ultimate Question 2.0 (Reichheld & Markey, 2011)

Also known as

  • Word-of-mouth economics: value of a promoter's referrals and cost of a detractor's negative comments
  • Value of a positive comment
  • Negative comment neutralisation ratio
  • Bad-profits audit: identifying policies that create detractors
  • Bad profits
  • Good profits

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Product Analytics & Strategy