Wigmore Evidence Charting

Description

Charts the full chain of inferences from each piece of evidence to the ultimate conclusion, including corroborating and contradicting evidence and the credibility of sources.

Wigmore devised a graphical notation for analysing masses of mixed evidence in legal cases: each proposition is a node, with symbols for testimonial and circumstantial evidence, explanatory and corroborative relations, and the analyst's belief in each. The key protocol is Anderson, Schum and Twining's seven-step method: clarify standpoint, formulate ultimate probanda (what must be proved), penultimate probanda, theories of the case, list evidence (key list), construct the chart, and refine. Schum extended it to probabilistic inference networks. For research synthesis across many studies, interviews and data sources, Wigmore charts make inferential chains auditable and reveal where conclusions rest on single, weak sources.

Attributes

Loss type
Extinct
Stage
Definition
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Clarify standpoint and the question the synthesis must answer.
  2. Formulate the ultimate proposition (e.g. 'small businesses will adopt automated bookkeeping if X') and the penultimate propositions it depends on.
  3. Compile a key list of all evidence items, noting source and credibility.
  4. Build the chart linking evidence through intermediate inferences to propositions, marking corroboration and contradiction.
  5. Assess the strength of each link and identify weak or single-source chains.
  6. Refine the conclusion and target new research at the weakest links.

Sources

  • Anderson, Schum & Twining, Analysis of Evidence (2nd ed., 2005)
  • Wigmore, The Principles of Judicial Proof (1913)
  • Schum, The Evidential Foundations of Probabilistic Reasoning (1994)

Also known as

  • Wigmore charts
  • Wigmorean analysis
  • Evidence marshalling

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor