Wicked problem framing

Description

Frames a design challenge using Rittel and Webber's ten characteristics of wicked problems, to decide how to approach it rather than prematurely solving it.

Rittel and Webber described wicked problems as having no definitive formulation, no stopping rule, solutions that are better or worse rather than true or false, no immediate test of a solution, every attempt counting, no enumerable set of solutions, uniqueness, being symptoms of other problems, multiple explanations, and planners having no right to be wrong. Wicked problem framing assesses a challenge against these characteristics and selects appropriate approaches: iterative and participatory processes, multiple framings, and argumentation-based methods such as Rittel's Issue-Based Information System (IBIS). In UX, the term is widely cited as a label for 'hard problems' but rarely applied as an analysis that changes method choice, which is why it is vestigial.

Attributes

Loss type
Vestigial
Stage
Strategy
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Write the problem statement as stakeholders currently express it.
  2. Assess it against the ten wickedness characteristics, scoring each as absent, partial or present with evidence.
  3. Collect alternative framings from at least 4-6 stakeholder groups, noting conflicting causal explanations.
  4. Map issues, positions and arguments using IBIS or dialogue mapping.
  5. Choose an approach suited to the degree of wickedness: iterative small experiments, participatory processes and explicit trade-off documentation.
  6. Define provisional success criteria and review points rather than a single solution test.

Sources

  • Gopinath, V., Methods Atlas (DSRP protocol)
  • PACT analysis (Dix; Benyon, Designing Interactive Systems)
  • Methods Atlas — DSRP protocol (Gopinath)
  • PACT analysis (Dix)
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 13 — DSRP Systems Thinking & Wicked Problems

Also known as

  • Wicked problem analysis
  • Problem structuring for wicked problems

Categories

  • Strategy & Collaboration
  • Systems & Complexity