Web Credibility Review

Description

Inspect a site or app's credibility cues against Stanford's ten guidelines and Fogg's grid of operator, content and design by presumed, reputed, surface and earned credibility.

Credibility is perceived trustworthiness and expertise. The Stanford Web Credibility Project found nearly half of people judged credibility mainly on visual design, and produced ten guidelines: make accuracy easy to verify, show a real organisation, highlight expertise, show honest and trustworthy people, make contact easy, look professional, be easy to use and useful, update content often, restrain promotions and avoid errors. Fogg's Web Credibility Grid crosses site elements (operator, content, design) with four credibility types: presumed (general assumptions), reputed (awards, seals, referrals), surface (first impressions) and earned (track record). Auditing each cell shows gaps and damaging cues and assigns ownership to design, content, marketing, legal or customer service. The aim is appropriate credibility, matching actual performance, not maximum credibility.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Identify which credibility contexts apply, such as advice, measurements, reported system state or simulations.
  2. Use the ten Stanford guidelines as a first-pass checklist and note shortfalls.
  3. Draw the grid (operator, content, design by presumed, reputed, surface, earned) and list positive and negative cues in each cell, such as ads mixed with content, broken links, typos or missing contact details.
  4. Prioritise significant errors over large but harmless ones, and check for over-claiming as well as under-claiming.
  5. Assign each cell to the team that controls it.
  6. Confirm key judgements with users, for example through first-impression tests, and re-audit after release since earned credibility builds over time.

Sources

  • UX Decoded (Kanungo, 2022)
  • Persuasive Technology (Fogg, 2003)
  • MIT Psychology (Stangor, 2012)

Also known as

  • Stanford web credibility guidelines review
  • Web credibility guidelines
  • Credibility checklist
  • Web Credibility Grid audit
  • Presumed-reputed-surface-earned audit

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation