Description
Users of one profile brainstorm everything an ideal system would offer under strict rules, then each privately picks a Top 5, giving needs scored by the percentage choosing them.
A structured focus-group variant producing prioritised requirements in about an hour. One piloted question asks about an ideal system in one of three forms: information, tasks or characteristics, neither so narrow it builds in a design nor so broad it invites irrelevant answers. Four rules are posted: it is an ideal system so all ideas are valid; no designing; the moderator may ask about duplicates; the scribe writes only the moderator's paraphrase. The moderator turns design suggestions back into underlying goals. Around 40 minutes of brainstorming typically yields about 100 numbered ideas. Each participant then completes a Top 5 booklet, one item per page with the reason it matters; picks are unranked and equally weighted, countering dominant voices. Items are grouped by meaning and scored as the percentage of participants choosing them, with at least two sessions per user profile checked for consistency before pooling.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Interviewing & Elicitation
- Loss type
- Vestigial
- Stage
- Discovery, Definition
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- With the product team, write one ideal-system question about information, tasks or characteristics and pilot it.
- Recruit 8-12 users of a single profile per session and run at least two sessions per profile, with a moderator, scribe and videographer.
- Post the question and the four rules, warm up and practise with a neutral example until everyone gives a valid idea.
- Brainstorm for about 40 minutes, probing design suggestions back to goals while the scribe numbers each paraphrased idea; avoid round-robin turns.
- Have each participant choose an unranked Top 5 in a booklet, giving the idea number, name, description and why it matters.
- Within 24 hours, sort booklet pages into groups of the same meaning, counting duplicate votes from one person once.
- Compute the percentage of participants choosing each group per session; check items chosen by at least half in one session appear in the other before pooling.
- Report a table ordered by percentage with exemplar quotes, plus the full idea list, and feed it into the specification.
Sources
- Understanding Your Users (Baxter et al., 2015)
- Understanding Your Users (1st ed.) (Courage & Baxter, 2005)
Also known as
- W&N analysis
- Wants and needs brainstorm
- Wants and Needs brainstorm with top-five booklet
- Ideal-system brainstorm with Top 5 booklet
- Ideal-system brainstorm with prioritisation
Categories
- User Research
- Interviewing & Elicitation