Video-Reflexive Ethnography

Description

Records participants' real practice on video and plays selected clips back to them, individually or in groups, to surface tacit knowledge and collectively reflect on how practice could change.

Video-reflexive ethnography (Iedema, Carroll, Collier) involves collecting video recordings of participants in their natural practice, then showing those recordings back to participants or groups to stimulate discussion and collaborative analysis. It is particularly powerful for: accessing tacit, embodied, and procedural knowledge that participants cannot easily describe verbally; stimulating collective reflection and learning in workplace settings; and revealing what is 'seen but unnoticed' in practice.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Discovery
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Video collection phase: Record participants in their natural practice with their knowledge and consent. Focus camera on the work activity rather than faces where possible — this shifts focus from person to practice.
  2. Clip selection: From the recordings, select 3–6 clips of 1–3 minutes each. Select clips that illustrate: (a) typical practices, (b) moments of complexity or adaptation, (c) moments you want participants to reflect on.
  3. Reflexive session: Play clips to participants (individually or in groups). Your role: facilitate observation, not evaluation. Opening prompt: 'What do you notice when you watch this?' Not: 'What did you do well or badly?'
  4. Capture participant observations: What do participants see in the video that they weren't aware of during the activity? These moments of 'I didn't realise I was doing that' are your primary data.
  5. Group reflexive sessions: Playing clips to groups generates collective reflection — participants compare practices, debate why things happened as they did, and negotiate shared understandings.

Sources

  • When Words Fail Us (PMC 2024)
  • Video-Reflexive Ethnography — Carroll et al.
  • Sage Handbook of Qualitative Data Collection (Flick)

Also known as

  • VRE
  • Video-reflexive interviewing
  • Video-stimulated reflection

Categories

  • User Research
  • Field & Ethnographic