Description
Build a consensus causal diagram of a system and its levers, then tag stakeholders' coded value statements onto the nodes that would need measuring, so values drive metric choices.
A ViMM joins two things usually kept apart: an expert model of how a system works and a record of what people affected by it care about. The team first draws a qualitative causal diagram with nodes, influence arrows and feedbacks, plus the levers available to one named decision maker. Stakeholder focus groups or interviews are then coded for evaluative statements, and each statement is attached to the node whose state would have to be measured to capture that concern, or to its nearest causal precursor. Concerns that share a scale can be lumped into value bins; ethically incommensurable ones are kept apart. The tagged diagram then guides which outcomes become metrics, which levers and causal chains are modelled, and where uncertainty analysis is spent, and it makes visible which values the analysis leaves out.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Systems & Complexity
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- With researchers, decision makers and domain experts, draw and revise a consensus diagram of the system's main variables, causal links and feedbacks, and mark the levers available to a named decision maker.
- Run focus groups or interviews about how stakeholders are or could be affected by the system and the levers; record and transcribe them.
- Code transcripts for evaluative statements, that is preferences or attitudes about outcomes, keeping a table of statement, speaker group and context.
- Attach each statement to the node that would have to be measured to quantify the concern, or to its closest causal precursor if that node is missing.
- Optionally bin statements into value categories, lumping concerns that share a common scale and splitting those that are ethically incommensurable.
- Use the tagged diagram to define metrics for each value, select levers that can move them, decide which causal chains to model and where to focus uncertainty analysis.
- Return to stakeholders to check nodes and tags, and record unrepresented values as explicit caveats.
Sources
- Integrating Values to Improve the Relevance and Inclusiveness of Climate-Risk Research (Helgeson et al., 2022)
Also known as
- ViMM
- Values-informed mental model
- Value-tagged system map
- Mapping stakeholder evaluative statements onto a system model
Categories
- Strategy & Collaboration
- Systems & Complexity