Values-Based Concept Assessment

Description

Participants rank three to five research-derived values, then place design concepts along a tape spectrum for each top value while thinking aloud, revealing why concepts appeal.

Rather than asking which concept people prefer, this method asks how concepts perform on values that matter to them. The team derives three to five values from prior research, such as feeling confident or staying in control. Participants rank and explain the values, which itself reveals priorities. For each top value a tape line is laid on a table or floor from most to least, and participants place concept cards along it while thinking aloud. Finally concepts are revisited without the values to discuss overall preference. The method deliberately avoids quantifying; its output is the reasoning behind placements, which shows which value each concept serves or threatens. Samples are small and the values are researcher-defined, so it is best for directional choices.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Derive three to five values from prior research.
  2. Have participants rank the values and explain their ranking.
  3. For each top value, lay a tape spectrum from most to least.
  4. Have participants place concept cards along the spectrum while thinking aloud.
  5. Repeat for the other top values.
  6. Revisit the concepts without values to discuss overall preference, then synthesise reasons by value.

Sources

  • Universal Methods of Design (Martin & Hanington, 2019)

Also known as

  • Values-based assessment
  • Value spectrum placement

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation