Value-Focused Thinking

Description

Starts from stakeholders' fundamental objectives, structured into hierarchies and means-ends networks, to generate better alternatives before evaluating them.

Most decision making is alternative-focused: compare the options on the table. Keeney argued for starting from values: eliciting what stakeholders fundamentally care about, distinguishing fundamental objectives (ends) from means objectives, structuring them into hierarchies and means-ends networks, and then using them to create new alternatives and evaluation criteria. Elicitation uses probes such as wish lists, problems, consequences, goals and perspectives. For UX, VFT gives a rigorous way to articulate user and business objectives and to escape narrow option sets in design debates. It links naturally to laddering and means-end research.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Interview stakeholders (and users) with Keeney's prompts: wish lists, problems, consequences, goals and different perspectives.
  2. Convert statements into objectives (verb plus object, e.g. 'minimise time to resolve billing issues').
  3. Separate fundamental from means objectives by asking 'why is that important?' and 'how could we achieve it?'.
  4. Build a fundamental objectives hierarchy and a means-ends network.
  5. Generate new alternatives aimed at each fundamental objective, including combinations.
  6. Define attributes to measure each objective and use them in evaluation (e.g. MAUT).

Sources

  • Keeney, Value-Focused Thinking: A Path to Creative Decisionmaking (1992)
  • Keeney, Developing objectives and attributes (2007), in Edwards, Miles & von Winterfeldt (eds.), Advances in Decision Analysis

Also known as

  • VFT
  • Keeney's value-focused thinking
  • Objectives hierarchy

Categories

  • Strategy & Collaboration
  • Game Theory & Decision Science