Description
Starts from stakeholders' fundamental objectives, structured into hierarchies and means-ends networks, to generate better alternatives before evaluating them.
Most decision making is alternative-focused: compare the options on the table. Keeney argued for starting from values: eliciting what stakeholders fundamentally care about, distinguishing fundamental objectives (ends) from means objectives, structuring them into hierarchies and means-ends networks, and then using them to create new alternatives and evaluation criteria. Elicitation uses probes such as wish lists, problems, consequences, goals and perspectives. For UX, VFT gives a rigorous way to articulate user and business objectives and to escape narrow option sets in design debates. It links naturally to laddering and means-end research.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Game Theory & Decision Science
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Stage
- Strategy, Definition
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Interview stakeholders (and users) with Keeney's prompts: wish lists, problems, consequences, goals and different perspectives.
- Convert statements into objectives (verb plus object, e.g. 'minimise time to resolve billing issues').
- Separate fundamental from means objectives by asking 'why is that important?' and 'how could we achieve it?'.
- Build a fundamental objectives hierarchy and a means-ends network.
- Generate new alternatives aimed at each fundamental objective, including combinations.
- Define attributes to measure each objective and use them in evaluation (e.g. MAUT).
Sources
- Keeney, Value-Focused Thinking: A Path to Creative Decisionmaking (1992)
- Keeney, Developing objectives and attributes (2007), in Edwards, Miles & von Winterfeldt (eds.), Advances in Decision Analysis
Also known as
- VFT
- Keeney's value-focused thinking
- Objectives hierarchy
Categories
- Strategy & Collaboration
- Game Theory & Decision Science