UX Maturity Levels Assessment (Games)

Description

A model of eight levels (0 to 7) that rates a studio's user research practice on staff and resources, dedicated budget, breadth of methods, depth of buy-in and evidence in released products, and says what to do next.

McAllister's model gives studios a roadmap for improving user research. It has eight levels, from Level 0 (does not know about UX research) and Level 1 (does not do it) through a 'have a go' approach and ineffective internal UX, to effective internal UX, outsourced UX, lifecycle UX and finally organisational UX, where research runs through company culture. Levels 0 to 3 may have no benefit or even make games worse; only from Level 4 are resources sufficient to reliably improve the player experience. Five variables place a studio: staff and resources (qualified staff, real participants, dedicated space, recruitment), dedicated budget planned per project, breadth of UX across the life cycle, depth of buy-in from the top down, and evidence, meaning whether released games are well reviewed and free of UX complaints. Each variable is rated by effort (none, low, moderate, sufficient). For each level the chapter lists signs that you are there, what to do next and when you are ready to move on. The evidence variable is notable because it checks outcomes, not just investment: if games still ship with usability issues despite research, the problem lies in process, communication or trust. The model can be used by any product organisation.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Stage
Strategy
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Gather information on research staff, facilities, recruitment and budget planning.
  2. Map which research methods are used across the development life cycle.
  3. Assess depth of buy-in: who reads reports and whether findings reach leadership.
  4. Review evidence from releases, such as review comments on usability problems.
  5. Rate each variable's effort level and match the profile to one of the eight levels.
  6. Use the level's guidance to pick next steps and the criteria for moving up.

Sources

  • Drachen, A., Mirza-Babaei, P. & Nacke, L. (eds), Games User Research (2018)

Also known as

  • Games UX maturity model
  • McAllister UX maturity levels
  • Eight-level UX maturity model

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor