UX Disease Agent Classification (Types I-IV)

Description

Classifies UX pathogens as cognitive, information architecture, interaction pattern or systemic, each needing different prevention and treatment strategies.

Medicine classifies disease agents (viral, bacterial, parasitic, environmental) because each requires different control strategies. The treatise proposes four UX agent types. Type I, cognitive pathogens, exploit or overwhelm attention, working memory, decision-making under uncertainty or framing susceptibility; most dark patterns belong here and are effective because the vulnerabilities are deep and universal. Type II, information architecture pathogens, systematically prevent users finding what they need and spread through shared templates and CMSs. Type III, interaction pattern pathogens, create systematic errors through misleading affordances, uninformative feedback or invisible status, and can 'mutate' when copied into contexts lacking the features that made them safe. Type IV, systemic pathogens, are structural features of platforms or industries, the hardest to address because they are not localised.

Attributes

Loss type
Community-proposed
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Collect candidate harmful patterns from audits, complaints and research.
  2. Classify each by type using the mechanism of harm, not surface appearance.
  3. Note transmission routes typical of the type (templates, libraries, incentives).
  4. Select control strategies suited to each type (literacy for Type I, IA standards for II, pattern library fixes for III, policy for IV).
  5. Track prevalence of each type over time.
  6. Revise the classification as new mechanisms appear.

Sources

  • Lost Methods in UX — A Complete Treatise (Gopinath)
  • Gray CM et al. (2018) The dark (patterns) side of UX design. CHI
  • Mathur A et al. (2019) Dark patterns at scale. CSCW

Also known as

  • UX pathogen typology
  • Cognitive, IA, interaction and systemic pathogens

Categories

  • Community-Proposed Frameworks