Uniframe Definition from Examples and Near-Misses

Description

Build one definition covering several examples by deciding, against near-miss contrasts, which relations to enforce, prevent or tolerate, and keep counter-examples as an explicit exceptions list.

A uniframe is a single description that applies to several different things. In Winston's arch example, comparing arches with near-misses shows that the top must be supported by two standing blocks (enforce), the standing blocks must not touch (prevent), and the top may be any shape (tolerate). Most differences between examples are redundant or accidental, and which features matter depends on how the definition will be used. When no single description fits, one keeps an accumulation of alternatives. Minsky's exception principle adds that a rule which nearly always works should not be patched endlessly but complemented by a list of exceptions. Adapted to UX synthesis, the procedure gives a disciplined way to define a category, persona boundary, design pattern or eligibility rule from cases, making explicit what is required, excluded and irrelevant.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Collect clear examples of the category and contrasting near-misses that differ in only one or two respects.
  2. Break each into parts with properties and relations.
  3. Compare each example with a near-miss and record the relation that must hold (enforce).
  4. Record relations that must not hold (prevent) and features to stay neutral about (tolerate).
  5. Drop differences that are redundant or accidental for the definition's intended use.
  6. If no single description fits, keep an accumulation of alternative descriptions.
  7. When a working rule meets a counter-example, add it to an exceptions list instead of rewriting the rule.

Sources

  • The Society of Mind (Minsky, 1986)

Also known as

  • Uniframe definition from examples and near-misses (enforce, prevent, tolerate)
  • Uniframing
  • Block-Arch learning
  • Enforce-prevent-tolerate definition
  • Exception principle

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis