Two-Column Case and Ladder of Inference

Description

Have people diagnose a short difficult conversation and script their own response, with unspoken thoughts in a left-hand column, to expose gaps between what they advocate and how they act.

Questionnaires and interviews capture espoused theories, what people say guides their actions. Argyris's case method gets at theories-in-use. Participants read a short exchange in which a manager gives a subordinate blunt feedback, diagnose and advise the manager, then script what they would say themselves, writing what they would think but not say in a left-hand column. Across about 1,000 respondents nearly everyone judged the manager ineffective, yet their own scripts repeated the same attributions or 'eased in' with leading questions, and they did not notice. Responses are analysed on a ladder of inference running from directly observable data through shared meanings to imposed attributions. In a self-generated version people write up a real problem of their own, and cases from one organisation reveal undiscussable topics and defensive routines.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Give a short transcript of a difficult conversation, or ask each participant to choose a real problem from their own work.
  2. Ask for a diagnosis of the actor and advice to them.
  3. Ask participants to script their own conversation, with spoken words on the right and unspoken thoughts and feelings on the left.
  4. Code diagnoses and scripts on the ladder of inference: observable data, culturally shared meanings, imposed meanings and attributions.
  5. Compare espoused advice with the theory-in-use shown in the scripts, feed the gaps back and discuss reactions.
  6. With a group from one organisation, look across cases for undiscussables, defensive routines and self-sealing reasoning.

Sources

  • Decision Making: Descriptive, Normative, and Prescriptive Interactions (Bell et al., 1988)

Also known as

  • Left-hand column case
  • Argyris X-Y case
  • Espoused theory versus theory-in-use case method
  • Ladder of inference analysis
  • Two-column (X-Y) case for diagnosing theories-in-use

Categories

  • User Research
  • Interviewing & Elicitation