Transformative (Participatory-Social Justice) Mixed Methods Design

Description

Run a mixed methods study inside a participatory or social justice frame, in revisitable phases from relationship building to use for change, so marginalised stakeholders shape and benefit from it.

A complex design in which core mixed methods designs are embedded within a framework that shapes the whole study: who sets questions, who is sampled, how results are used. Mertens grounds it in a transformative axiology (cultural respect, addressing inequities, reciprocity, action, relationships), an ontology of multiple socially positioned realities, and an epistemology that honours lived experience and addresses power. Six phases are linked by two-way arrows and revisited as information arrives: building relationships, analysing context including history and power, piloting with stakeholders, implementing with ongoing qualitative feedback on a quantitatively monitored intervention, determining effectiveness with mixed data, and using results for transformative purposes. Strategies borrowed from activism, such as coalition building, and planning for sustainability raise impact. It takes time and trust, and power dynamics reassert themselves unless addressed explicitly.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Data
Mixed
Effort
Months

Steps

  1. Build relationships with affected communities and identify who must be included, especially marginalised groups.
  2. Analyse the context, including history, regulation and power relations.
  3. Co-design and pilot instruments or the intervention with stakeholders, deciding together how sensitive topics are approached.
  4. Implement, using ongoing qualitative feedback to adjust an intervention monitored quantitatively.
  5. Determine effectiveness with mixed data, disaggregated by the groups the study aims to serve.
  6. Use results for change and plan for sustainability, revisiting earlier phases as new information arrives.

Sources

  • The Sage Handbook of Mixed Methods Research Design (Poth, 2023)
  • Research Design (5th ed.) (Creswell & Creswell, 2018)

Also known as

  • Transformative mixed methods design
  • Transformative cyclical design
  • Multi-stage transformative mixed methods design
  • Mixed methods participatory-social justice design

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor