Description
Read each transcript line by line and turn every reasoning step, reaction or guiding principle into a first-person, verb-first summary with a verbatim quote, before comparing across people.
Combing is Indi Young's line-by-line extraction of what a person was really trying to do. In the 2008 version each phrase expressing an action, thought, feeling or philosophy becomes an atomic first-person verb+noun task with a verbatim quote, typically 60-120 per hour-long transcript; preferences, desires, facts, explanations and complaints are excluded or logged separately. In the 2015 version, which Young prefers as less product-focused, quotes are gathered into discrete concepts (one reasoning step, reaction or guiding principle) and each gets a one-sentence summary: chosen verb first, first person, present tense, emotions written as 'feel' plus an emotion, and no compound sentences. Summaries carry their quotes and participant IDs. Only after this are patterns aggregated across people, and participants with similar reasoning in a given scene form behaviour-named segments, with a different set of segments per scene.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Stage
- Discovery, Definition
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Study each person's material for at least 10 minutes before writing anything, re-listening or reading the transcript.
- Highlight phrases that express a reasoning step, reaction or guiding principle; skip explanation, facts, opinions, preferences, generalisations and conjecture.
- Gather quotes for each discrete concept and tag them with participant ID.
- Write one summary per concept: brainstorm three or four verbs, prefer the speaker's own, first person, present tense, one sentence with the reason after the verb, emotions as 'feel' plus an emotion.
- Check one summary per concept and one concept per quote; read aloud and have a colleague or the speaker check it.
- Note 'fillers' you supplied and probe them in the next session.
- After all sessions, aggregate summaries into patterns and group people with similar reasoning per scene into behaviour-named segments.
Sources
- Mental Models (Young, 2008)
- Practical Empathy (Young, 2015)
Also known as
- Combing transcripts for tasks
- Combing
- Task extraction
- Atomic task coding
- Concept summaries
- Verb-first summaries
- Behavioural segments from reasoning patterns
- Thinking-style segments
Categories
- User Research
- Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis