Description
A four-stage check, before prototyping, of whether others understand and feel an idea as intended: rehearsal, expert critique, delayed playback by non-experts, and re-imagining.
Iyengar rejects asking people whether they like an idea, citing evidence that likes mostly reflect social influence, and instead checks whether others form the intended image and feeling. Listen to Yourself: write the idea, say it aloud, write what you said from memory, and repeat until fluent. What Works: describe it to experts and ask only what worked and why, what did not and why, and how they would improve it, steering away from liking and prediction. Playback: explain it to non-experts in under five minutes and have them describe it back; a day or two later, unannounced, ask again; the drift shows what is memorable, what feelings it raises, and which unfamiliar parts are replaced by familiar ones. Third Eye Test: invite people to change the idea however they like, ask only clarifying questions, and compare versions.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Design & Product Practice
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Definition
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Write the idea, say it aloud, write down from memory what you said, edit, and repeat until fluent; then tell it to a listener who gives no reaction.
- What Works: describe the idea to experts and ask what worked and why, what did not and why, and how they would improve it; continue until nothing new emerges.
- Playback: explain the idea to non-experts in under five minutes, ask them to describe it back, and thank them without discussion.
- A day or two later (a week or more for insiders), unannounced, ask them to describe it again and compare with your version.
- Ask subjective prompts: what does it conjure up, how does it make you feel.
- Third Eye Test: describe the full solution, ask several people to change it as they see fit, ask only clarifying questions, and compare versions.
- Revise the idea statement before deciding whether to build.
Sources
- Think Bigger (Iyengar, 2023)
Also known as
- Third Eye
- What Works
- Playback
- Listen to Yourself
- Idea comprehension feedback sequence
Categories
- Design
- Design & Product Practice