Thinking-Style Sensitivity

Description

Identifying early in an interview whether a participant thinks sequentially, simultaneously or reactively, then adapting probes and stimuli to fit.

Participants do not all access and report experience the same way. Sequential thinkers narrate chronologically and resist 'why' questions before context is set; simultaneous thinkers jump across linked threads and generate rich but tangled material; reactive thinkers struggle with abstract recall but respond in detail to a concrete stimulus. In the first few minutes the interviewer asks about a recent concrete experience and observes which pattern appears, then adjusts: following chronology and asking 'what happened next' for sequential thinkers, tracking and later reconstructing threads for simultaneous thinkers, and introducing screenshots, prototypes or artefacts for reactive thinkers. The aim is to reduce the mismatch between interviewer style and participant cognition that produces thin data.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Stage
Discovery
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. In the first 3–5 minutes: ask an open question about a recent, concrete experience related to your research topic. Observe: does the participant describe events in sequence (sequential), jump between related ideas (simultaneous), or wait for you to offer a specific stimulus (reactive)?
  2. Adjust your probing style for the rest of the session based on the observed thinking style.

Sources

  • Practical Empathy (Indi Young)
  • Mental Models (Indi Young)
  • Listening (Blee)
  • Practical Empathy (Young)
  • Mental Models (Young)
  • Qualitative Interviewing
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 32 — Advanced Elicitation — The Archaeology of the Interview

Also known as

  • Adaptive probing
  • Sequential/simultaneous/reactive thinker adaptation

Categories

  • User Research
  • Interviewing & Elicitation