Theatre-Based Scenario Elicitation

Description

Acted scenarios of future technology use, live or filmed, are shown to potential users who discuss or role-play them to elicit requirements and reactions.

Drama gives non-technical audiences something concrete to react to before anything is built. Scenarios of a concept in use are scripted and performed by team members, actors or professional theatre companies, sometimes with props, video or Wizard-of-Oz robots. In the focus troupe form, short vignettes are played to a focus group and discussed one by one. Newell et al. worked with a scriptwriter to make assistive-technology scenarios with human interest, humour and tension; videos had stopping points where older people, carers and designers discussed what was happening. Brandt and Grunnet built simple dramatised scenes from home interviews and later had users role-play with a prototype. Theatre-based HRI puts actors and remote-controlled robots on stage and lets audiences question actors in character. Drama helps people imagine themselves in scenarios and helps designers empathise.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Discovery, Design
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Interview or observe potential users to ground the scenarios in real situations.
  2. Script a few short scenes showing the concept in context, including moments of difficulty; use a professional writer for emotionally complex topics.
  3. Rehearse and perform live, or film the performance with planned stopping points; use Wizard-of-Oz control for robots or devices.
  4. After each scene, facilitate discussion of what happened, where the technology would help or annoy, and what is missing; let audiences question actors in character if useful.
  5. Capture reactions by notes, questionnaires and interviews, comparing across scenes.
  6. Optionally return with a prototype and ask users to role-play scenarios of use in their own setting.

Sources

  • Experience-Centered Design (Wright & McCarthy, 2010)
  • Understanding Your Users (Baxter et al., 2015)
  • HCI Encyclopedia (Soegaard & Dam, 2014)

Also known as

  • Focus troupe
  • Dramatised scenarios
  • Dramatised Scenarios and Theatre in Requirements Gathering
  • Drama and role-play in design
  • Playacting focus group
  • Dramatic vignette focus group
  • Theatre-based HRI (THRI)
  • Robot theatre scenario prototyping

Categories

  • Design
  • Participatory, Design & Futures