Temporal and Spatial Occlusion Paradigm

Description

Cuts off or masks parts of a realistic dynamic display at chosen moments to find out when and from which cues skilled people predict what will happen next.

In temporal occlusion, footage of an unfolding event is filmed from the performer's viewpoint and edited so that it stops at set points (for example before, at and after a key moment); participants say what happens next. Experts' advantage at the earliest cut-off points shows how much they extract from advance cues. In spatial occlusion, specific areas (such as an opponent's arm) are masked throughout, and a drop in accuracy when a region is removed shows that the region carries information the person uses. Variants use point-light displays to strip away surface detail, occlusion goggles in live settings, and combination with eye tracking and verbal reports. The Handbook notes that expert-novice differences grow as stimuli and responses become more realistic. For UX and human factors the paradigm transfers to any dynamic display where users must anticipate: monitoring dashboards, security and video surveillance, trading screens, driving and drone interfaces, games. It tells designers which elements expert users actually rely on to see trouble coming, and whether a redesign removes or hides those cues.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Record or simulate realistic sequences of the dynamic display, from the user's normal viewpoint, with known outcomes.
  2. Define temporal cut-off points relative to key events, and spatial masks over candidate information regions.
  3. Recruit groups differing in expertise (for example experienced operators and new hires).
  4. Present clips in random order and ask for a prediction or decision with confidence after each.
  5. Score accuracy and response time by cut-off point and by masked region, comparing groups.
  6. Combine with eye tracking or retrospective verbal reports to confirm which cues are used.
  7. Feed results into display design (keep or emphasise the predictive cues) and into training scenarios.

Sources

  • Tenenbaum, G. & Eklund, R. (eds), Handbook of Sport Psychology, 3rd ed. (2007)

Also known as

  • Temporal occlusion
  • Spatial occlusion
  • Film occlusion paradigm
  • Event occlusion
  • Liquid crystal occlusion goggles method

Categories

  • User Research
  • Cognitive Psychology & Perception