Technological Mediation Analysis

Description

Analyses how a product invites or inhibits actions and amplifies or reduces perceptions, then removes undesirable mediation or deliberately designs in desirable mediation.

Because technologies shape what people do and how they perceive the world, designers are always doing ethics, implicitly or explicitly. Verbeek's mediation analysis makes this explicit. Mediation of action is examined through scripts (Latour: a ceramic cup's script is to be washed, a cardboard cup's to be thrown away), affordances and multistability, the fact that one artefact supports different uses in different contexts; designs invite or inhibit behaviour. Mediation of experience is examined through embodiment relations, where the artefact withdraws into the body like glasses, and hermeneutic relations, where it represents the world and must be read like a thermostat; each amplifies some aspects of perception and reduces others. Verbeek offers a minimum scenario (find and reduce undesirable mediation) and a second scenario (design in desirable mediation).

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Describe the product's script: which actions it invites and which it inhibits, and how use varies across contexts (multistability).
  2. Describe its relation to experience: embodiment or hermeneutic, and what it amplifies or reduces in perception.
  3. Anticipate mediations in several use contexts and for different stakeholders, including non-users.
  4. Judge which mediations are undesirable and reduce or eliminate them (minimum scenario).
  5. Decide which mediations are desirable and build them in (second scenario), for example aesthetics that make a target behaviour attractive.
  6. Optionally measure the values at stake with users, for example with Schwartz's value theory, to check the intended mediation occurs.

Sources

  • HCI Encyclopedia (Soegaard & Dam, 2014)

Also known as

  • Verbeek's mediation analysis
  • Design ethics via technological mediation
  • Script analysis (Latour)

Categories

  • Design
  • Participatory, Design & Futures