Taxonomy of Loss

Description

Classifies how research methods disappear (extinct, vestigial, siloed, renamed, latent) and, with cause of loss, locates priority targets for recovery.

The treatise defines a lost method as one that (a) was once practised with regularity and rigour, (b) has largely disappeared from practice, education or discourse, and (c) retains significant value if recovered. Its taxonomy has five types: Extinct (no current practitioners; knowledge only in literature; the methodological community has dissolved), Vestigial (practised in reduced or distorted form; original intent and theory lost, leaving a surface procedure), Siloed (active in academic or specialist contexts but absent from industry), Renamed (rebranded without credit or theoretical connection to origins) and Latent (known but rarely used; infrastructure for revival exists). The extended edition adds unmigrated methods, rigorous in donor disciplines but never adopted. Appendix A crosses survival degree with cause of loss (legitimate validity failure versus illegitimate organisational pressure); high-value, low-survival methods are recovery priorities.

Attributes

Loss type
Community-proposed
Stage
Strategy
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Inventory methods used in or relevant to the organisation or field.
  2. Check each against the three lost-method criteria.
  3. Assign a loss type: extinct, vestigial, siloed, renamed, latent or unmigrated.
  4. Assess the cause of loss, distinguishing validity failure from organisational pressure.
  5. Plot methods by potential value and current survival.
  6. Select high-value, low-survival methods for recovery.

Sources

  • Lost Methods in UX — A Complete Treatise (Gopinath)
  • Kuhn TS (1962) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions

Also known as

  • Method loss classification
  • Types of methodological disappearance

Categories

  • Community-Proposed Frameworks