Description
A named set of 13 moves for drawing conclusions from a qualitative display, from noting patterns and counting up to building a logical chain of evidence and conceptual coherence.
Miles and Huberman argue that every display is worked through a flow of specific tactics, and they name them so analysts can use and report them deliberately. Ordered roughly from descriptive to explanatory, they are: (1) noting patterns and themes; (2) seeing plausibility; (3) clustering; (4) making metaphors; (5) counting; (6) making contrasts and comparisons; (7) partitioning variables; (8) subsuming particulars into the general; (9) factoring, a qualitative analogue of factor analysis; (10) noting relations between variables; (11) finding intervening variables; (12) building a logical chain of evidence; and (13) making conceptual and theoretical coherence. Each comes with cautions: patterns 'just happen' almost too quickly and need scepticism, further evidence and openness to disconfirmation; plausibility is a pointer to a conclusion worth checking, not a basis for it. The chapter shows a bottom-up path from discrete findings, to relating them, naming the pattern and finding a construct, likened to abduction. Throughout the book's displays, the tactic used at each step is flagged in bold. For UX researchers the list is a vocabulary and checklist for synthesis: it makes visible how a theme was reached and which moves (for example counting or finding intervening variables) were never tried.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Discovery, Definition
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Lay out the data in a display (matrix, network or clustered notes).
- Note patterns and clusters, and treat early plausible conclusions as pointers to check, not findings.
- Count occurrences and make contrasts and comparisons across people, segments or cases.
- Partition variables that turn out to be too broad, and subsume particulars into more general categories or factors.
- Look for relations between variables and for intervening variables that explain them.
- Build a logical chain of evidence and connect it to concepts or theory; record which tactics produced each conclusion.
Sources
- Miles, M. & Huberman, A. M., Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2nd ed. (1994)
Also known as
- Thirteen tactics for generating meaning
- Miles and Huberman meaning-making tactics
- Conclusion-drawing tactics
Categories
- User Research
- Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis