Tactics for Generating Meaning

Description

A named set of 13 moves for drawing conclusions from a qualitative display, from noting patterns and counting up to building a logical chain of evidence and conceptual coherence.

Miles and Huberman argue that every display is worked through a flow of specific tactics, and they name them so analysts can use and report them deliberately. Ordered roughly from descriptive to explanatory, they are: (1) noting patterns and themes; (2) seeing plausibility; (3) clustering; (4) making metaphors; (5) counting; (6) making contrasts and comparisons; (7) partitioning variables; (8) subsuming particulars into the general; (9) factoring, a qualitative analogue of factor analysis; (10) noting relations between variables; (11) finding intervening variables; (12) building a logical chain of evidence; and (13) making conceptual and theoretical coherence. Each comes with cautions: patterns 'just happen' almost too quickly and need scepticism, further evidence and openness to disconfirmation; plausibility is a pointer to a conclusion worth checking, not a basis for it. The chapter shows a bottom-up path from discrete findings, to relating them, naming the pattern and finding a construct, likened to abduction. Throughout the book's displays, the tactic used at each step is flagged in bold. For UX researchers the list is a vocabulary and checklist for synthesis: it makes visible how a theme was reached and which moves (for example counting or finding intervening variables) were never tried.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Lay out the data in a display (matrix, network or clustered notes).
  2. Note patterns and clusters, and treat early plausible conclusions as pointers to check, not findings.
  3. Count occurrences and make contrasts and comparisons across people, segments or cases.
  4. Partition variables that turn out to be too broad, and subsume particulars into more general categories or factors.
  5. Look for relations between variables and for intervening variables that explain them.
  6. Build a logical chain of evidence and connect it to concepts or theory; record which tactics produced each conclusion.

Sources

  • Miles, M. & Huberman, A. M., Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2nd ed. (1994)

Also known as

  • Thirteen tactics for generating meaning
  • Miles and Huberman meaning-making tactics
  • Conclusion-drawing tactics

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis