SWAT (Subjective Workload Assessment Technique)

Description

Measures workload on time load, mental effort and psychological stress, scaled with each user's own conjoint-measured weighting of the three dimensions.

SWAT asks users to rate workload on three dimensions, each with three levels: time load, mental effort load and psychological stress load. What makes it rigorous is the scale development phase: before the task, each participant sorts 27 cards representing all combinations of levels by perceived workload, and conjoint measurement converts the sort into an interval scale from 0 to 100 unique to that person or group. Event ratings are then mapped onto this scale. SWAT thus respects individual differences in what feels demanding. It is more laborious than NASA-TLX, which displaced it, but its conjoint foundation makes it an instructive example of psychometric rigour in workload measurement.

Attributes

Loss type
Extinct
Stage
Evaluation
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Explain the three dimensions and their three levels to participants with standard descriptors.
  2. Run the card sort: each participant ranks all 27 combinations from lowest to highest workload.
  3. Apply conjoint scaling to derive interval workload values; check Kendall's coefficient of concordance to decide between group and individual scales (group scale if W >= 0.75).
  4. After each task or event, collect quick 1-2-3 ratings on the three dimensions.
  5. Convert ratings to scaled workload scores and compare conditions or task segments.
  6. Triangulate with performance and physiological measures.

Sources

  • Reid & Nygren, The subjective workload assessment technique (1988), in Hancock & Meshkati (eds.), Human Mental Workload

Also known as

  • SWAT

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error