Description
Record and integrate surface electrical activity over the muscles doing a task and compare it across control designs, alongside time and error, as a measure of physical effort.
Muscle action potentials are brief spikes repeated hundreds of times a second; summed and smoothed, they trace tension building and fading in the muscles doing the work, and can be picked up from electrodes on the skin without surgery. Early human factors research used this integrated signal to judge controls: in Jenkins and Connor's tracking study, people turned a knob to keep a marker on a moving target under different control ratios, and integrated muscle activity ranked the ratios almost exactly as time on target and error counts did. Electrodes interfere with movement far less than mechanical recorders, and the signal shows effort that performance measures can hide when people compensate. Modern practice adds what the 1950 account lacks: standard electrode placement, filtering and normalisation to each person's maximum voluntary contraction so that conditions and people can be compared.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Human Factors & Error
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Quantitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Identify the muscles that do the work in the task (for example forearm flexors and extensors for a knob or mouse, shoulder muscles for mid-air gestures).
- Place surface electrodes over those muscles following a standard placement guide, with a reference electrode, after preparing the skin.
- Record a maximum voluntary contraction for each muscle so that task activity can be expressed as a percentage of maximum.
- Have participants perform the same task under each control arrangement (for example different control-display ratios or input devices) in counterbalanced order.
- Rectify, filter and integrate the signal over each trial and express it as a percentage of maximum voluntary contraction.
- Compare integrated muscle activity across conditions together with time on target, errors and subjective effort, and look for conditions where performance is similar but effort differs.
Sources
- Physiological Psychology (Morgan & Stellar, 1950)
Also known as
- Surface EMG of working muscles
- EMG evaluation of control-display arrangements
- Integrated EMG effort measure
- Muscle action potential recording for control design
Categories
- Accessibility
- Human Factors & Error