Structured analogue observation with scripted partners

Description

Build a lab analogue of an everyday situation by scripting the setting, a partner's behaviour or the task, so rare behaviours occur reliably and can be compared across people.

Naturalistic observation is costly and misses rare, hidden or reactive behaviours such as conflict, frustration or help-seeking. Analogue observation raises their frequency by structuring one of three things: the social setting (who is present, group size, task), a partner's behaviour (a trained confederate who cheats and taunts in a rigged game, or a parent trained to respond contingently), or the task and response options (a disappointing prize, a waiting task, a rigged failure). Every participant then has the same chance to show the behaviour, allowing comparison across people and occasions. Sessions are video recorded and coded with a defined scheme, sometimes combined with physiology and video-cued self-report, as in Hubbard's rigged game. Elicited negative emotion is kept brief and mild, and participants are debriefed. For UX, it is a rigorous form of scripted-confederate or rigged-failure testing.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Evaluation
Data
Mixed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Define the target behaviour (frustration, conflict, help-seeking, recovery) and why it is rare or hard to observe naturally.
  2. Choose what to structure: the setting, a partner's behaviour or the task and response options.
  3. Script and train any confederate or partner; standardise prompts, timing and the rigged events.
  4. Record sessions on video and code behaviour with a defined scheme; add physiology or video-cued self-report where useful.
  5. Keep elicited negative emotion brief and mild, and debrief participants fully about scripting or rigging.
  6. Check representativeness against naturalistic data, logs or other informants.

Sources

  • Handbook of Child Psychology Vol 3 (Lerner & Lamb, 2015)

Also known as

  • Structured analogue observation with scripted partners and rigged tasks
  • Analogue observation
  • Confederate paradigm
  • Rigged-game paradigm
  • Social challenge method

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Experimentation & Causal Inference