Structural Dimensional Analysis of Mental Representation (SDA-M)

Description

Uses a repeated anchored split task, hierarchical clustering and invariance tests to map how people mentally group the steps of a skilled action and compare that structure with experts or with the task's functional structure.

SDA-M measures how a set of action elements (basic action concepts, such as the sub-movements of a tennis serve) is organised in long-term memory. It has four steps. First, a split procedure: one element is shown as a fixed anchor and the participant judges, for every other element, whether it is functionally related to the anchor while performing the action; each resulting subset is split again until the participant stops, and every element takes a turn as anchor. This produces a distance scaling between all pairs. Second, hierarchical cluster analysis turns the distances into a dendrogram for each person. Third, a factor analysis with cluster-oriented rotation identifies dimensions. Fourth, invariance analysis tests whether structures differ within and between groups, or from a reference structure. In the Handbook, expert tennis players' structures matched the biomechanical phases of the serve while non-players' did not. For UX the same procedure can map how users mentally structure multi-step workflows, gesture sequences or procedures, and show where novices' structures diverge from the intended workflow model or from experts.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Stage
Discovery, Design
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. With experts, define 8 to 15 elements of the workflow or action, each with a short label and image or screenshot.
  2. Familiarise participants with all elements.
  3. Run the split procedure: present each element in turn as an anchor and have participants mark the others as related or unrelated, then split each subset again until they stop.
  4. Compute pairwise distances and run hierarchical cluster analysis for each participant and group.
  5. Use invariance analysis to compare individuals, groups and a reference structure such as the designer's intended model.
  6. Interpret where novice clusters break from expert or intended structure, and target those points in onboarding or interface grouping.

Sources

  • Tenenbaum, G. & Eklund, R. (eds), Handbook of Sport Psychology, 3rd ed. (2007)

Also known as

  • SDA-M
  • Structural dimensional analysis-motoric
  • Basic action concept analysis
  • Split procedure mental representation analysis

Categories

  • User Research
  • Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling