Strategy and Value Proposition Canvases

Description

Two canvases: a strategy canvas plotting how you and rivals perform on factors customers value, and a value proposition canvas matching customer jobs, pains and gains to an offering.

The strategy canvas lists factors of competition along the horizontal axis and relative performance from low to high on the vertical, with one value curve per organisation; differentiation shows where curves diverge, and blue ocean logic seeks trade-offs that make rivals irrelevant. Kalbach's experience-based variant uses journey phases (become aware, purchase, use, renew, get support) as the factors, giving an experience view of competition. The value proposition canvas has a customer profile (jobs to be done, pains, gains) and a value map (products and services, pain relievers, gain creators); where relievers and creators answer real pains and gains there is potential fit. Both are only as good as their inputs: factors, ratings, jobs and pains should come from research such as journey maps or mental model diagrams, and the fit they suggest must be validated with the market.

Attributes

Loss type
Active
Stage
Strategy
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Determine the factors customers value (or the journey phases) using research such as alignment diagrams or interviews.
  2. Choose a limited set of competitors, ideally three and no more than four.
  3. Rate each competitor on each factor on a relative low-to-high scale, backed by evidence such as surveys where possible, and plot the value curves.
  4. Look for divergence, over-served factors and trade-offs that could differentiate.
  5. For the value proposition canvas, fill in the customer profile (jobs, pains, gains) from research.
  6. Fill in the value map (products and services, pain relievers, gain creators) and map relievers to pains and creators to gains.
  7. List the assumed fits as hypotheses and validate them with customers before committing.

Sources

  • Mapping Experiences (Kalbach, 2016)
  • Blue Ocean Strategy (Kim & Mauborgne, 2005)
  • UX Strategy (Levy, 2015)

Also known as

  • Strategy canvas
  • Value curve
  • Blue ocean strategy canvas
  • Experience-based strategy canvas
  • Value proposition canvas
  • VPC

Categories

  • Design
  • Design & Product Practice