Strange loop audit

Description

Finds paths where navigation or system logic loops back on itself, so that users moving 'forward' or 'up' end where they started, often without realising it.

Hofstadter's strange loop is a hierarchy that, by moving consistently in one direction, returns to its starting level. In interfaces this appears as settings that link to help that links back to settings, 'back' that re-opens the dialog it closed, error recovery that leads to the step that caused the error, or authentication flows that bounce between login and verification. Such loops are invisible locally, because each step is sensible, but trap users globally. The audit models the navigation and recovery structure as a directed graph, detects cycles with algorithms such as Tarjan's strongly connected components, then classifies each cycle as intentional (hub-and-spoke returns) or pathological (no exit towards the goal). Rigour comes from including error, timeout and back-stack behaviour in the graph.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Stage
Evaluation
Data
Mixed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Map navigation and recovery behaviour as a directed graph, including back, cancel, errors, timeouts and deep links.
  2. Run cycle detection (Tarjan's or Johnson's algorithm) to list strongly connected components and elementary cycles.
  3. For each cycle, check whether at least one exit edge leads closer to the user's goal or a safe state; flag cycles with none as pathological.
  4. Validate flagged loops against session logs, looking for repeated sequences (for example the same 3-screen sequence occurring 3 or more times in a session).
  5. Observe 5-8 users on flagged tasks to confirm whether they recognise the loop and how they escape.
  6. Redesign to break the loop with an explicit exit, state preservation or escalation path, and re-run cycle detection.

Sources

  • Hofstadter, D., Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid (1979)
  • Weyers, B., Bowen, J., Dix, A. & Palanque, P. (eds), The Handbook of Formal Methods in Human-Computer Interaction (2017)
  • Gödel Escher Bach (Hofstadter)
  • Handbook of Formal Methods in HCI
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 6 — Strange Loops, Recursive Failures & Navigation Traps

Also known as

  • Recursive loop audit
  • Self-reference loop audit
  • Navigation loop audit

Categories

  • Strategy & Collaboration
  • Systems & Complexity