Description
Decide whether one option's whole outcome distribution beats another's for every decision maker in a broad class, without choosing a utility function, and test the verdict by permutation.
Comparing two designs by their means hides what happens in the tails. Stochastic dominance asks a stronger question: would every person whose preferences meet some mild conditions prefer option A? First-order dominance (A's cumulative distribution lies at or below B's everywhere) covers anyone who prefers more to less; second-order dominance (the running integral of the CDF difference never favours B) adds risk aversion; third and fourth orders add prudence-type conditions and apply to ever narrower classes of people. Anderson's matrix algorithm computes all orders from binned probabilities, and Vinod adds an optional probability-weighting transform for decision makers who depart from expected utility and a permutation test to judge whether an apparent dominance could arise by chance. An indeterminate result is itself informative: the choice then depends on whose preferences count.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Game Theory & Decision Science
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Stage
- Evaluation, Post-launch
- Data
- Quantitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Pool the outcome samples for the two options and divide the common range into class intervals starting just below the minimum.
- Compute each option's probability in every interval and cumulate them to empirical CDFs; integrate the CDF differences once, twice or three times for second-, third- and fourth-order comparisons.
- Optionally transform the cumulative probabilities with a probability-weighting function to represent people who overweight rare outcomes.
- Take the largest difference in each direction as the test statistic for each order.
- Build the null distribution by randomly reassigning pooled observations to groups of the original sizes (about 999 permutations) and declare dominance only if the observed statistic reaches the 95th percentile.
- Report A over B, B over A or indeterminate at each order; when screening many options against a benchmark, rank by the cumulated dominance vector and check the leaders with bootstrap intervals.
Sources
- Preparing for the Worst: Incorporating Downside Risk in Stock Market Investments (Vinod & Reagle, 2005)
Also known as
- Stochastic dominance test
- 1SD/2SD/3SD/4SD
- First-order stochastic dominance
- Second-order stochastic dominance
- Anderson's stochastic dominance test
- Distribution dominance comparison
- Stochastic dominance ranking of alternatives (first to fourth order)
Categories
- Strategy & Collaboration
- Game Theory & Decision Science