Description
Replaying recordings of a participant's own session to cue detailed retrospective accounts of what they were thinking at specific moments.
Stimulated recall separates doing from explaining. The participant first works naturally, unburdened by concurrent think-aloud, while screen, audio and optionally eye-tracking are recorded. Soon afterwards, ideally within 24 hours, the researcher plays back the recording and pauses at pre-selected moments such as hesitations, errors or unusual actions, asking what the participant was thinking, trying to do and expecting. Because the recording shows behaviour, probing targets cognition: decisions, expectations and interpretations of feedback. Analysis maps cognitive events onto behavioural events, and mismatches between what participants believed they were doing and what the recording shows are the richest data. It avoids reactivity of concurrent verbalisation, at the cost of some reconstruction risk that increases with delay.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Interviewing & Elicitation
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Stage
- Evaluation, Discovery
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Recording phase: Record the participant's work session (screen + audio + optionally eye-tracking). This recording is the stimulus material — not data to be analysed independently.
- Interview phase (immediately after or within 24 hours): Play back the recording. Pause at pre-selected moments (moments of hesitation, errors, unusual behavior). Ask: "What were you thinking here?" "What were you trying to do at this point?" "What did you expect to happen?"
- Probing for thought, not behavior: The recording shows behavior. The retrospective interview accesses the cognitive process behind behavior. Target: thoughts about decisions, expectations, and interpretations — not descriptions of what they did (the recording shows that).
- Analysis: Code for cognitive processes: error detection, goal clarification, interpretation of feedback, decision points. Map cognitive events to behavioral events in the recording. Mismatches between what the participant thought they were doing and what the recording shows are the richest data.
Sources
- Observing the User Experience (Goodman)
- Research Methods in HCI (Lazar)
- Thought Processes in Lectures and Discussions (Bloom)
- Garcia-Ruiz, M. (ed.), Games User Research: A Case Study Approach (2016)
Also known as
- Retrospective think-aloud
- Video-cued recall
- Cued retrospective interview
Categories
- User Research
- Interviewing & Elicitation