Stakeholder and Requirements Trade-off Matrices

Description

Tabulate goals or business-model levers against each stakeholder group's priorities and quality criteria to expose shared goals, conflicts and who wins or loses before negotiating.

Two traditions make trade-offs between stakeholders explicit. In requirements engineering, Sutcliffe lists goals gathered separately from each stakeholder group as matrix rows; each group's priority is marked with one to three ticks, neutral or conflict marks, and further columns record associations with non-functional criteria such as accuracy, security and usability. The matrix shows how few goals are shared and where conflicts lie, so they can be negotiated in a facilitated workshop. In business strategy, Kaplan decomposes how a firm makes money into an ROIC tree of revenue and cost drivers, asks for each lever which stakeholders it helps or harms, names externalities, and sets measures and targets, complemented by direct engagement with affected stakeholders and critics. Both turn vague tension into a concrete, discussable table.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Gather goals separately from each stakeholder group, or decompose the business model into value drivers (revenue, cost and capital levers).
  2. List the goals or levers as rows of a matrix.
  3. For each stakeholder group, mark priority (one to three ticks), neutral (-) or conflict (--); for levers, mark who gains and who bears costs.
  4. Add columns for quality criteria (security, accuracy, usability) or impact measures, and mark associations.
  5. Identify shared goals, conflicting goals and externalities, and set measures and targets for the main impacts.
  6. Bring affected stakeholders, including critics, into a facilitated session to negotiate conflicts, explaining the effect of contested goals.

Sources

  • HCI Encyclopedia (Soegaard & Dam, 2014)
  • The 360° Corporation (Kaplan, 2019)

Also known as

  • Requirements trade-off analysis
  • Goal-NFR prioritisation matrix
  • Stakeholder trade-off analysis
  • Who wins, who loses analysis
  • ROIC tree with stakeholder overlay

Categories

  • Design
  • Design & Product Practice