Stages-of-Action Gulf Analysis

Description

Walk each user goal through Norman's seven stages of action to locate where the gulfs of execution and evaluation are widest and derive design fixes.

Norman's action cycle has seven stages: form the goal, form the intention (plan), specify the action, perform it, perceive the system state, interpret it and compare it with the goal. Mismatches between what users intend and what the interface allows form the gulf of execution; mismatches between how the system shows its state and what users expect form the gulf of evaluation. As an analysis, each important goal gets a table with one column per stage, filled by answering Norman's questions (What do I want? What are the alternatives? What can I do now? How do I do it? What happened? What does it mean? Is this okay?). Each boundary is checked against four failure points from Polson and Lewis: inadequate goal, object not found, action not known, and missing or misleading feedback. A scope check then asks which stages before and after the product's current coverage it should support.

Attributes

Loss type
Vestigial
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. List the users' main goals and pick representative tasks, stating each goal in the user's terms.
  2. For each goal build a table with columns Goal, Plan, Specify, Perform, Perceive, Interpret, Compare and answer Norman's question for each stage.
  3. At each step check the four failure points: inadequate goal, interface object not found, action not known, feedback missing or misleading.
  4. Classify each problem as a gulf of execution or evaluation and identify the features that widen or narrow it.
  5. Check problems against visibility, conceptual model, mapping and feedback, and derive design rules or features that remove whole iterations of the cycle.
  6. Widen the frame by listing stages of the user's activity before and after the product's scope, and decide whether to support them.
  7. Summarise all goals in one table to compare tools or versions, then confirm the main gulfs with usability testing.

Sources

  • Designing the User Interface (Shneiderman et al., 2018)
  • The Handbook of Formal Methods in HCI (Weyers et al., 2017)
  • Human-Computer Interaction (Dix et al., 2004)

Also known as

  • Seven Stages of Action Gulf Analysis
  • Stages-of-action analysis
  • Norman's seven stages of action
  • Gulf of execution and gulf of evaluation analysis
  • Action cycle walkthrough
  • Norman's action theory analysis
  • Seven stages of action inspection
  • Abowd and Beale interaction framework

Categories

  • User Research
  • Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling