Description
Record ideas on a standard one-pager, filter them in stages with knock-out then weighted criteria, and archive rejects in a pool rather than deleting them.
Staged screening manages the flow of ideas from all sources into product concepts. Every idea is documented the same way on a one-page form with categorisation and stored in a first pool. A broad, cheap screen against mandatory minimum requirements (knock-out criteria such as strategic fit or legal feasibility) removes about half, which are archived in a separate pool for later reconsideration rather than deleted. The remaining ideas are substantiated while being evaluated against finer, weighted desirable criteria, leaving about 30 percent of the original number. These become concepts for final selection. Criteria may be quantitative or qualitative, and techniques range from verbal assessment and checklists to yes/no screens, paired comparison and utility value analysis. The logic is to spend little on each idea early and reserve costly evaluation for the few that survive.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Design & Product Practice
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Goal
- Prioritise, Support a decision
- Stage
- Strategy, Definition
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Collect ideas from all sources on a standard one-page form (problem, idea, target users, category, source).
- Define knock-out criteria (mandatory minimum requirements) and desirable criteria with weights before screening.
- Screen the first pool against the knock-out criteria; archive rejects in a separate pool with the reason.
- Substantiate surviving ideas with light evidence and evaluate them against the weighted criteria, using checklists, paired comparison or utility value analysis.
- Develop the top ideas (around 30 percent of the original intake or fewer) into product concepts.
- Make a final selection and periodically revisit the archive when strategy or technology changes.
Sources
- Innovation and Product Management (Gaubinger et al., 2015)
Also known as
- Idea funnel
- Idea pool screening
- Idea one-pager
Categories
- Design
- Design & Product Practice