Spradley's Developmental Research Sequence (Domain, Taxonomic and Componential Analysis)

Description

A step-by-step ethnographic method that builds cultural domains from semantic relationships, organises them into taxonomies, and identifies the contrasting attributes that define terms.

Spradley's twelve-step sequence alternates interviewing and analysis. Domain analysis finds cultural categories using universal semantic relationships (X is a kind of Y; X is a way to do Y; X is a reason for Y). Structural questions elicit members of domains. Taxonomic analysis organises domains into hierarchies; contrast questions and componential analysis identify the dimensions of contrast (attributes) that distinguish terms. Finally, themes are discovered across domains. This produces an emic map of how users categorise their world, extraordinarily useful for information architecture, terminology and mental model work, and far more systematic than open-ended 'tell me about' interviews.

Attributes

Loss type
Extinct
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Conduct descriptive interviews and collect native terms used by participants.
  2. Perform domain analysis using Spradley's semantic relationships to identify cover terms and included terms.
  3. Ask structural questions to complete domains (e.g. 'what are all the kinds of X?').
  4. Build taxonomies showing hierarchical relations among terms; verify with participants.
  5. Ask contrast questions and build a componential paradigm of attributes distinguishing terms.
  6. Discover cultural themes across domains and relate them to design.

Sources

  • Spradley, The Ethnographic Interview (1979)
  • Spradley, Participant Observation (1980)
  • Goodenough, Componential analysis and the study of meaning (1956), Language

Also known as

  • Developmental research sequence
  • Domain analysis
  • Taxonomic analysis
  • Componential analysis
  • Ethnosemantics

Categories

  • User Research
  • Field & Ethnographic