Speech act analysis

Description

Classifies what each system and user utterance does, such as requesting, committing, declaring or informing, to check that interface language performs the intended acts.

Austin and Searle showed that utterances perform actions. Searle's five classes are assertives (stating), directives (requesting), commissives (committing), expressives (expressing attitude) and declarations (changing reality by saying, such as 'You are now signed in'). Interface language performs these acts: a button labelled 'I agree' is a commissive; 'Order placed' is a declaration. Speech act analysis classifies messages and actions by their illocutionary force and checks felicity conditions (is the speaker entitled, are conditions met, is the act sincere?). Winograd and Flores built the Coordinator system on speech acts in the 1980s; the approach faded but is directly relevant to conversational AI. Rigour comes from explicit classification and checking each act's conditions and consequences.

Attributes

Loss type
Extinct
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Collect system messages, button labels and conversational turns in a flow.
  2. Classify each by Searle's five classes and note the intended act.
  3. Check felicity conditions: does the system have authority, are preconditions met, is the commitment real and fulfilled?
  4. Identify mismatches, such as a message that reads as a declaration ('Payment sent') when the act is only a request.
  5. Validate high-risk mismatches with 5-10 users asking what they believe has happened or been committed to.
  6. Rewrite to align surface language with the real act and its status.

Sources

  • Gleason, J. B., The Development of Language
  • Hall, E., Conversational Design (2018)
  • Gopinath, V., Methods Atlas (Gricean audit)
  • Development of Language (Gleason)
  • Conversational Design (Hall)
  • Methods Atlas — Gricean audit (Gopinath)
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 18 — Pragmatics — What Language Actually Does

Also known as

  • Speech act theory analysis
  • Illocutionary act analysis

Categories

  • Content
  • Linguistics, Semiotics & Discourse