Speculative and Design Fiction Research

Description

Uses plausible fictional products, interfaces or scenarios as research probes to elicit participants' values, concerns and assumptions about technology futures.

Speculative design research (Dunne & Raby; Bleecker) uses designed artefacts that do not yet exist — products, interfaces, scenarios for possible futures — as research stimuli. By asking participants to respond to plausible-but-fictional designs, researchers access values, concerns, and assumptions about technology that participants cannot easily articulate in relation to existing products. Design fiction is particularly powerful for: exploring long-term implications of current design trajectories, surfacing values that only become visible when confronted with design choices, and including participants in discussions about technology futures.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Design the speculative artefact: Create a designed object, interface, or scenario for a plausible-but-not-yet-existing product. Diegetically: produce it as if it exists — packaging, marketing materials, instruction manual — to increase the sense of reality.
  2. Brief participants without framing its status: Present the speculative design as you would a real product: 'We're working on something new. Here's an early version. What do you think?'
  3. Elicit responses: Observe what participants attend to, what they accept without question, and what they question or resist. Each question or acceptance reveals an assumption.
  4. Defamiliarisation elicitation: After initial reactions, reveal that the design is speculative. Then: 'What does this design imply about how [organisation / technology / society] should work?' The juxtaposition of real and fictional elicits values.
  5. Analysis: Analyse: what futures did participants accept as inevitable? What futures did they resist? What values did their responses reveal? These are your findings about participants' implicit assumptions about technology and society.

Sources

  • Speculative Everything (Dunne & Raby)
  • Design Fiction (Bleecker)
  • Research Design (Leavy)

Also known as

  • Design fiction
  • Speculative design research
  • Critical design as research

Categories

  • Design
  • Participatory, Design & Futures