Sound Design Review Checklist

Description

Inspection checklists that review every product sound for purpose, trigger, urgency, context, missed-notification backup, inclusion and real-world listening conditions.

Products accumulate beeps, chimes and spoken prompts that are rarely reviewed as a system. Case and Day offer two checklists. At design time each sound, taken from an audio map of product states, is checked for purpose (is sound needed at all), trigger, information and urgency, the product's location relative to the user, what happens if the notification is missed and whether another sense backs it up, whether it can interrupt others or play at the wrong time, durability when heard many times a day, and inclusivity. After contextual testing a final checklist groups faults under Sound (distortion, pitch, volume, cannot be turned off), Time (ill-timed, mismatched with the interface, duration, frequency), Attention (urgency, no reason, interrupts others), Inclusion, and Conditions such as noisy places, other rooms, transit or poor connectivity.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Build an audio map listing every product state that produces or could produce sound.
  2. For each state, answer the design-time questions: purpose, trigger, information and urgency, location, missed-notification backup, context, durability and inclusivity.
  3. Test sounds in real conditions: quiet and loud places, another room, in transit, in a bag, at night, with poor connectivity.
  4. Test durability by playing each sound repeatedly over a full day.
  5. Run the final checklist under Sound, Time, Attention, Inclusion and Conditions and record failures per state.
  6. Feed failures into redesign of sounds, settings (adjust, change, turn off) or modality.

Sources

  • Designing with Sound (Case & Day, 2018)

Also known as

  • Sound interaction and contextual review checklist
  • Sound design checklist
  • Final contextual testing checklist

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation