Social Impact Statement

Description

An early, short, reviewable document stating a new system's goals, stakeholders, benefits, risks and safeguards, reviewed and enforced by a panel.

Modelled on environmental impact statements, the social impact statement makes anticipated impacts of a system public while change is still cheap. Shneiderman and Rose's outline has about twenty headings in three groups: describing the system (goals, stakeholders, benefits); addressing concerns (barriers, job changes and layoffs, security and privacy, accountability for misuse and failure, bias, individual rights against social benefit, centralisation, democratic principles, diverse access, keeping what works); and outlining the development process (schedule, decision process, stakeholder involvement, training, backups, migration and success measures). It is written early by a team that can include end users and managers, kept short enough for affected people to read, and submitted to a review panel such as a regulator, professional body or union that holds hearings, requests changes and later checks that actions match stated intentions.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Decide whether the system's reach justifies a statement, for example public services, regulated industries or large workforces.
  2. Draft it before schedule, requirements and budget are fixed, with a team that includes end users and managers.
  3. Cover the system description, stakeholder benefits, concerns (jobs, privacy, accountability, bias, access, rights) and the development and migration plan with success measures.
  4. Keep it short and readable for the people affected.
  5. Submit it to a review panel and to affected groups; hold hearings and invite citizen or employee input.
  6. Revise as requested, adopt it, and have the panel audit later that actions matched the stated intentions.

Sources

  • Designing the User Interface (Shneiderman et al., 2018)
  • Quantitative Social Research Methods (Singh, 2007)

Also known as

  • SIS
  • Social impact analysis
  • Technology impact statement

Categories

  • Design
  • Participatory, Design & Futures