Description
Participants judge single-domain acts against criteria (wrong without a rule, if authority allowed it, elsewhere) to reveal whether they treat a norm as moral, conventional or personal.
Social domain theory holds that people distinguish moral matters (harm, fairness, rights), conventional matters (manners, dress, forms of address) and personal matters (choice of friends, recreation). Participants hear brief scenarios, each involving only one domain, and judge the act's acceptability. Criterion questions then ask whether it would still be wrong if there were no rule, if an authority permitted it, if everyone agreed, or if another culture accepted it, and how serious it is. Justifications are coded as harm, welfare, fairness, rights, convention or personal choice. Moral judgements prove non-contingent across many cultures, from age three, while conventional ones are contingent. A variant uses neutral-faced drawings and asks how the actor, recipient and observer feel. For UX, the method shows whether users treat a product norm (data sharing, community rules, AI behaviour) as a matter of ethics, etiquette or personal choice.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Interviewing & Elicitation
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Stage
- Discovery, Definition
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Write short scenarios, each involving only one domain, since mixed-domain acts confound judgements.
- Ask whether the act is acceptable and how serious it is.
- Ask the criterion questions: wrong without a rule, wrong if an authority allowed it, wrong if everyone agreed, wrong in another place or culture.
- For emotion attribution, show neutral-faced drawings and ask how each party feels.
- Ask for justifications and code them (harm, fairness, rights, convention, personal choice) with two coders.
- Compare judgement patterns across domains, scenarios and participant groups.
Sources
- Handbook of Child Psychology Vol 1 (Lerner et al., 2015)
- Wiley-Blackwell Handbook of Childhood Cognitive Development (Goswami, 2011)
Also known as
- Social-domain criterion-judgment interview
- Criterion judgments
- Social domain interview
- Moral-conventional distinction task
- Domain criterion-judgement interview with neutral-faced scenario drawings
Categories
- User Research
- Interviewing & Elicitation