Situational Analysis

Description

Extends grounded theory by mapping a whole situation, including human and nonhuman elements, social worlds, arenas and discursive positions, through situational, social-worlds and positional maps.

Situational Analysis (Adele Clarke, 2005) extends Grounded Theory by mapping the full situation — including nonhuman elements, discourses, and structural conditions — rather than focusing only on human actors and their meanings. It produces three types of maps: situational maps (all elements), social worlds/arenas maps (collective actors and their negotiations), and positional maps (discursive positions on key debates). Applied to UX: it reveals all the stakeholders, artefacts, and competing discourses shaping the product situation, not just the individual user's experience.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Messy situational map: Brainstorm every element in the situation — human actors, nonhuman elements (artefacts, technologies, infrastructure), implicitly implied elements, symbolic elements, discursive constructs, political/economic factors. Put every element on the map regardless of apparent importance.
  2. Ordered situational map: Organise the messy map into categories: individual human, collective human, discursive, nonhuman, political/economic, temporal/historical, spatial/geographic.
  3. Social worlds/arenas map: Identify the collective actors (social worlds — those sharing a particular commitment or practice) and the arenas (sites of ongoing negotiation between those worlds).
  4. Positional map: For each major controversy or debate in the situation: map out the positions that are taken. Each position occupies a location on axes defined by the key dimensions of the debate. This reveals which positions are represented, which are absent, and which might be silenced.

Sources

  • Situational Analysis (Adele Clarke)
  • Grounded Theory in Practice (Strauss & Corbin)
  • Sage Handbook of Qualitative Data Analysis (Flick)

Also known as

  • Clarke's situational analysis
  • Situational mapping
  • Grounded theory after the postmodern turn

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis