Description
Members each draft a detailed solution alone, then present them in turn while the group names each one's strengths and merges them step by step into one solution.
SIL (from the German for successive integration of solution elements) is a convergent ideation format for complex problems with few feasible solutions, such as industrial or product design tasks. An interdisciplinary group of six to eight frames the problem precisely; each member then drafts a detailed solution alone, which avoids the production blocking and anchoring of open brainstorming. The first two solutions are presented and discussed for their strengths only, and the group builds an integrated solution from both. Each further solution is presented, its strengths identified and folded into the growing combined concept. The session takes two to three hours and demands more of participants and moderator than brainstorming, but produces mature solutions that the whole group feels it owns. It combines the individual work of brainwriting with the group discussion of brainstorming, and it is closer to synthesis than to idea generation.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Design & Product Practice
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Stage
- Design
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- Frame the problem precisely with six to eight people from different specialisms.
- Give each participant 20-30 minutes to draft a solution alone, in as much detail as possible (sketches welcome).
- Participant 1 presents; the group discusses and records only its strengths.
- Participant 2 presents; the group records its strengths.
- The group builds an integrated solution from the strengths of both.
- Each further solution is presented, its strengths identified and integrated into the combined solution.
- End with one or more comprehensive integrated concepts and record which elements came from which draft.
Sources
- Innovation and Product Management (Gaubinger et al., 2015)
Also known as
- SIL method (systematic integration of problem elements)
- SIL-Method
- Blender
- Successive integration of solution elements
Categories
- Design
- Design & Product Practice