Semiorder and Interval-Order Check of Preference and Indifference Judgements

Description

Check whether pairwise preference and indifference judgements can be explained by one underlying scale plus a just-noticeable threshold, by testing two four-item conditions and then fitting the threshold.

People often say they are indifferent between A and B and between B and C yet prefer A to C, because small differences go unnoticed. Luce's semiorder explains this with a scale and a threshold: one option is preferred only when its value exceeds the other's by more than a just-noticeable amount. The interval order is the weaker version in which the threshold may vary by item. Both are testable from ordinal data. The interval-order condition forbids two strict preferences whose cross pairs are both indifferent; the semiorder adds that whenever a beats b and b beats c, every other item must be below a or above c. If both hold, the scale order and threshold can be constructed. With choice probabilities, calling a preferred when P(a, b) exceeds a level gives a family of semiorders whose consistency is checked through weak stochastic transitivity and independence.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Record for each pair whether one option is strictly preferred or the two are judged indifferent, directly or by declaring a preferred when its choice probability exceeds a chosen level such as 0.75.
  2. Check the interval-order condition: for all a, b, c, d, if a beats c and b beats d, then a beats d or b beats c.
  3. Check the semiorder condition: if a beats b and b beats c, every other item must be below a or above c.
  4. If both hold, derive the underlying order and construct a scale with a constant or upper threshold.
  5. Across several decisiveness levels, test weak stochastic transitivity and weak independence to see whether all levels share one scale.
  6. Optionally test whether the threshold grows with scale value (Weber's law).

Sources

  • Foundations of Measurement, Vol. 2: Geometrical, Threshold, and Probabilistic Representations (Suppes et al., 1989)
  • Foundations of Measurement, Vol. 1: Additive and Polynomial Representations (Krantz et al., 1971)

Also known as

  • Threshold (jnd) representation of intransitive indifference
  • Interval order test
  • Luce semiorder test
  • Scott-Suppes conditions
  • Semiorder check

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Behavioral Science & Economics