SEM Reporting Checklist

Description

A stage-by-stage checklist for planning, reporting or reviewing a structural equation model so that its specification, fit, modifications and validity can be judged and replicated.

Reviews of published SEMs found recurring faults: a single fit index, no cross-validation, weak theoretical grounding, missing data and no consideration of rival models. The checklist responds by asking specific questions at each stage. Data preparation: population, measurement level, descriptives, multivariate normality, missing data handling (FIML or imputation), outliers, transformations, the correlation, mean and SD table, and the matrix analysed. Specification: rationale, latent variable definitions, theory for measurement and structural parts, alternative models, exploratory or confirmatory status, sample size and power, expected signs and a diagram. Identification: distinct values, free parameters, order and rank conditions. Estimation: estimator choice, convergence, Heywood cases, scaling, software version and start values. Testing: several fit indices, composite reliability, validity, invariance, unstandardised paths with standard errors and standardised values. Modification: one change at a time with justification and equivalent models. Validation: replication, split-sample cross-validation and bootstrap.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Evaluation
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Data preparation: describe the population, measurement levels, descriptives, normality, amount and handling of missing data, outliers, transformations and the matrix analysed; share data and syntax where possible.
  2. Specification: state the rationale, latent variable definitions, theory, alternative models, exploratory or confirmatory status, sample size justification, hypotheses with expected signs, and an initial diagram.
  3. Identification: report the number of distinct values and free parameters and how order and rank conditions are met.
  4. Estimation: justify the estimator, and report convergence problems, Heywood cases, scaling choices, software version and R-squared values.
  5. Testing: report at least two fit indices with their criteria, reliability and validity evidence, invariance tests where groups are compared, and unstandardised paths with standard errors or intervals alongside standardised values.
  6. Modification and validation: document each change one at a time with its justification, consider equivalent models, show initial and final diagrams, and cross-validate on a split or new sample.

Sources

  • A Beginner's Guide to Structural Equation Modeling (Schumacker & Lomax, 2004)
  • Latent Variable Models (Loehlin & Beaujean, 2017)
  • How to Perform and Report an Impactful Analysis Using Partial Least Squares (Benitez et al., 2020)

Also known as

  • Structural equation model checklist
  • SEM reporting standards
  • Thompson's ten commandments of SEM
  • Communicating about latent variable models (reporting guidance)

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor