Description
Uses five social threat and reward domains to plan and run design critiques and stakeholder reviews so feedback does not trigger defensiveness.
David Rock's SCARF model proposes that people respond to social situations through five domains of perceived threat or reward: Status, Certainty, Autonomy, Relatedness and Fairness. Tom Greever's work on articulating design decisions shows how stakeholder resistance often stems from these social threats rather than from the design itself. Applied to critique facilitation, the facilitator plans how each domain might be threatened (a stakeholder losing face, unclear next steps, decisions imposed without input, in-group versus out-group dynamics, unequal treatment) and designs the session to reduce threat: clear agendas, criteria-based feedback, explicit decision rights and acknowledgement of contributions. The neuroscientific claims are heuristic; rigour lies in consistent preparation, criteria agreed in advance, and documenting decisions.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Participatory, Design & Futures
- Loss type
- Latent
- Goal
- Communicate findings
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- SCARF-safe critique protocol:
- Status — begin by acknowledging what works ('this navigation structure is really clear').
- (2) Certainty — explain the basis for feedback ('this pattern conflicts with users' expectations based on [research]').
- (3) Autonomy — offer options, not mandates ('we could address this by either X or Y').
- (4) Relatedness — frame feedback as shared problem-solving, not evaluation.
- (5) Fairness — apply the same criteria to all design decisions.
Sources
- Articulating Design Decisions — Tom Greever
Also known as
- SCARF
- Status Certainty Autonomy Relatedness Fairness
Categories
- Design
- Participatory, Design & Futures