Description
Present dilemmas in which harming one person saves five, varying how personal the harm is, and compare how often people judge the action acceptable.
Sacrificial dilemmas hold the arithmetic constant, one dies so five live, and vary how the harm is done. Most people accept switching a runaway trolley onto a side track, fewer accept pushing a stranger off a footbridge or out of a lifeboat, and almost no one accepts a surgeon killing a visitor to harvest organs. Greene and colleagues linked the personal versions to emotional responses in the brain, and people with stronger autonomic arousal or intact ventromedial prefrontal cortex are less likely to endorse the utilitarian act. Unlike the Kohlberg moral dilemma interview, which elicits reasoning, this paradigm measures endorsement rates across matched variants. In product research it is used to study public expectations of automated decision systems, such as how autonomous vehicles should trade off harms, and how framing and agency change acceptance. Koenigs and colleagues (2007) used a three-way set worth copying: nonmoral control scenarios, impersonal moral dilemmas and personal moral dilemmas; patients with ventromedial prefrontal damage answered like controls on the first two but endorsed personal harms far more often.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Behavioral Science & Economics
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Data
- Quantitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Prepare dilemmas with the same outcome trade-off that differ in how personal or direct the harm is (redirecting a threat, pushing, direct killing), or in whether a person or a machine acts, and include nonmoral control scenarios alongside impersonal and personal moral dilemmas so that differences can be attributed to moral content rather than general decision style.
- Present each dilemma with neutral wording and ask whether the action is acceptable (yes or no, or a rating).
- Counterbalance order and include filler dilemmas to reduce consistency pressure.
- Optionally record response times or physiological arousal while participants consider each dilemma.
- Compare endorsement rates across variants, agents and participant groups.
Sources
- Biological Psychology (Kalat, 2019)
- On Second Thought: Outsmarting Your Mind's Hard-Wired Habits (Herbert, 2010)
- Physiology of Behavior (Carlson & Birkett, 2017)
Also known as
- Trolley problem paradigm
- Footbridge dilemma
- Personal versus impersonal moral dilemmas
- Utilitarian dilemma judgement task
- Sacrificial moral dilemmas (trolley, footbridge, lifeboat, hospital)
Categories
- Analytics & Behaviour
- Behavioral Science & Economics