Description
Iteratively asks why a problem occurred to move from symptoms to systemic causes, ideally with evidence at each step and multiple branches.
The 5 Whys asks 'why' repeatedly until reaching a cause that, if fixed, prevents recurrence. In disciplined form, each answer must be verified with evidence, branches are allowed when there are several causes, and the analysis stops at a cause within the organisation's control, usually a process or design decision rather than a person. Formal RCA (as in healthcare, per The Joint Commission) adds timeline reconstruction, cause-and-effect charting and action hierarchies that favour design changes over retraining. The method is vestigial in UX: teams ask 'why' five times in a meeting with no evidence, follow a single linear chain and stop at 'user didn't read'. Restoring the evidence and branching rules makes it rigorous.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Human Factors & Error
- Loss type
- Vestigial
- Stage
- Post-launch, Evaluation
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- State the problem precisely with measurable symptoms, scope and time window.
- Reconstruct a factual timeline from logs, recordings and interviews before any causal discussion.
- Ask why the problem occurred and record each candidate cause, requiring evidence (data, observation, reproduction) for every link.
- Allow branching where several causes contribute, and continue each branch until reaching a controllable process or design cause, typically 3-7 levels.
- Reject causes that blame individuals; reframe as 'why was this error possible and not caught'.
- Select corrective actions using an action hierarchy (forcing functions and automation stronger than warnings and training) and set a verification metric.
Sources
- Ohno, Toyota Production System: Beyond Large-Scale Production (1988 English ed.)
- Card, The problem with '5 whys' (2017), BMJ Quality & Safety
- The Joint Commission, Framework for Root Cause Analysis and Corrective Actions
Also known as
- RCA
- 5 Whys
- Five whys
- Causal analysis
- Ask why
Categories
- Accessibility
- Human Factors & Error