Role-Ordered Matrix

Description

A matrix whose rows are people grouped by role, ordered by distance from the work, and whose columns are research sub-questions, so views can be compared within and across roles.

How people see a situation depends partly on their role. The role-ordered matrix sorts data by 'role occupants'. A general question (how do people react to an innovation when they first meet it) is unbundled into sub-questions such as what is salient, how they size it up, what changes they expect and how well it fits previous practice; these become columns. Rows are individual people clustered into roles and ordered by how far they sit from the action, from direct users through department heads to central administrators, so both within-role and between-role comparisons are possible. The analyst decides who to include (direct users, those with a stake, key administrators), summarises each person's view in a phrase, and marks 'DK' where data are missing. Reading down columns, the book's analyst found teachers saw the programme as prescriptive while administrators took a big-picture view and saw no need for organisational change. For UX this is a direct way to set out how designers, product managers, engineers, support staff and customers each perceive the same feature or problem.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Break the main question into three to six sub-questions to use as columns.
  2. Decide which roles to include and list individuals as rows, grouped by role and ordered by distance from the product or work.
  3. Search coded notes for each person and enter a short phrase or quote per cell; mark DK where data are missing or ambiguous.
  4. Read down columns within each role, then compare across roles.
  5. Use counting and comparison to test apparent differences, and go back to notes for reasons.
  6. Summarise role-perspective differences and their implications.

Sources

  • Miles, M. & Huberman, A. M., Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2nd ed. (1994)

Also known as

  • Role-ordered display
  • Perspective-by-role matrix

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis