Risk and Time Preference Elicitation (Holt-Laury and Discounting Tasks)

Description

Incentivised choice lists that measure individual risk aversion and impatience, used to segment users and predict responses to risky or delayed rewards.

Holt-Laury presents ten paired lotteries with increasing probability of the high payoff; the switching point between safe and risky options indexes risk aversion under expected utility. Delay discounting tasks offer choices between smaller-sooner and larger-later amounts, estimating discount rates and present bias (beta-delta models). Using real incentives for a randomly selected choice keeps answers honest. These measures predict behaviour in savings, insurance, health and subscription contexts. For UX, they explain why some users respond to annual plan discounts, loss framing or delayed rewards and others do not, and they offer validated covariates for heterogeneous treatment effects.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Choose the instruments (Holt-Laury list, a delay discounting list such as Kirby's 27-item questionnaire) and incentive scheme.
  2. Administer with clear instructions and pay one randomly chosen decision for real.
  3. Identify switching points; flag inconsistent multiple switching for exclusion or special handling.
  4. Estimate risk aversion (e.g. CRRA coefficient) and discount parameters (k or beta-delta) per participant.
  5. Relate parameters to product behaviours (plan choice, savings, adherence) or use them as moderators in experiments.
  6. Design framing or reward timing variations for segments with different preferences.

Sources

  • Holt & Laury, Risk aversion and incentive effects (2002), American Economic Review
  • Frederick, Loewenstein & O'Donoghue, Time discounting and time preference: A critical review (2002), Journal of Economic Literature
  • Kirby & Maraković, Delay-discounting probabilistic rewards (1996), Psychonomic Bulletin & Review

Also known as

  • Holt-Laury lottery
  • Multiple price list
  • Delay discounting task
  • Time preference elicitation

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Behavioral Science & Economics